Wagner Insurance Agency is independently owned and locally operated to handle your insurance needs. We offer affordable and reliable insurance choices all across Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, Indiana, West Virginia, Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee. We will help you find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to fit your needs.
Choice
We work with a wide range of quality, reliable insurance companies and can provide coverage options for any business or personal insurance need.
Experience
Our staff has been working in the industry for many years. We offer guidance and help you make the right decisions for yourself, your family, or your business.
Service
We take care of our customers like family. We're here for you – whether to provide a rate, assist with a claim, expand your coverage, or just answer questions.
Three Local Ohio Insurance Offices
Dayton, Ohio
937-223-2232
1050 South Main Street
Dayton, OH 45409
Monday - Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm
West Milton, Ohio
937-698-4124
308 South Miami Street
West Milton, OH 45383
Monday - Friday 8:00am - 4:30pm
Lebanon, Ohio
513-932-2831
3 N Broadway St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Monday - Friday 8:00am - 4:30pm
Our Insurance Companies
Insurance We Offer
Auto Insurance
We're experts in finding affordable and complete Ohio auto insurance. Request a quote and let us find the right coverage for you.
Home Insurance
Ohio homeowner insurance rates can vary widely. We'll make sure you're properly covered at the lowest rate available.
Business Insurance
Let us review your Ohio business insurance needs. It's vital for your business to have the proper coverage in case you ever need it.
Life Insurance
Life changes, and your insurance policy should evolve with it. Contact us for the best selection of affordable Ohio life insurance choices.
Latest Blog Articles
How Moving Impacts Your Personal Insurance
Wednesday, May 6, 2026
Moving to a new home comes with a long list of tasks, and insurance updates are often overlooked in the process. However, a change in location, property type, vehicles, and daily routines can all affect your coverage...
Factors That Impact Your Car’s Resale Value
Monday, April 6, 2026
A vehicle is one of the larger purchases most people make, and its value changes over time. While some depreciation is expected, certain factors can influence how much your car is worth when it comes time to sell or...
Related Video
Auto-Owners "Fire"
Quick Links
© 2026 Wagner Insurance Agency | Search | Privacy | Disclaimer